Betty'sPies & Tarts
County Road 2 · Cobourg, Ontario

Award-winning butter tarts, baked the homemade way.

A little maroon sign, a case full of pies and tarts, and ribbons on the wall to prove it. Come find us between Port Hope and Cobourg.

See what's in the case Find us
★★★★★ Loved by locals & road-trippers on the buttertart trail
Made fresh, the old-fashioned way

What we bake

Everything is homemade in small batches. The butter tarts are the headliners — but the pies, squares and cookies have their own loyal following.

Butter Tarts

Our award-winners — plain, raisin, pecan and more, with that signature glossy filling.

Fresh Pies

Apple, pumpkin, strawberry-rhubarb and the seasons in between — whole or by the slice.

Squares & Brownies

Fudgy brownies, coconut squares and a rotating case of homemade treats under the glass domes.

Cookies & More

Cookies, scones and small-batch baking that change with what's good that week.

🎖 Ribbons on the wall

A roadside bakery worth the drive

Betty's sits in a little brick shop on County Road 2, right between Port Hope and Cobourg. Pull up to the maroon sign and the bonnet-lady out front, and you'll find a case full of homemade pies, squares and the tarts people keep coming back for.

Those butter tarts aren't just local legend — they've taken home ribbons at the fair, and there's a wall of them inside to prove it. Everything is baked in small batches the old-fashioned way.

Whether you're on the butter-tart trail or just driving past, it's the kind of stop that turns into a regular habit.

The heritage corner inside Betty's: a vintage cream stove, framed award ribbons and the hand-painted bonnet-lady mascot
Come say hello

Find us on County Road 2

Address
7380 County Road 2, Cobourg, ON K9A 4J7
Between Port Hope & Cobourg
Hours
Open most days — call ahead for today's hours
Hours can change seasonally and around holidays.
Betty's Pies and Tarts storefront: brick shop with yellow awnings, an OPEN neon sign and autumn pumpkins out front